Presented by:
Valerie Seidel, Balmoral Group Australia
Hanna Fiegenbaum, European Commission
Stuart Martin, University of Technology Sydney
Liz Heagney, Skjander & Farming for the Future
Workshop Objectives
The main objective of the workshop is to facilitate dialogue on an emerging line of evidence that Finance and Science sectors are talking past each other on topics of natural capital and in particular biodiversity. The aim is to introduce some perspectives that are heard less often by economists, namely that of lenders, funders, and participants in the capital markets. The specific theme will be the myriad of biodiversity and natural capital metrics that exist and continue to be introduced, but bear little resemblance to the needs of the Finance sector to identify some unit of measure at scale. The tools to be explored include the sets of metrics employed by scientists (Essential Biodiversity Variables, etc.) versus those employed by Financial professionals. The knowledge gap we have repeatedly encountered is the lack of common language between producers or stewards of natural capital, and the Finance actors with capital to deploy across a range of mechanisms. At the World Biodiversity Forum in Davos this year, Becky Chaplin-Kramer reminded the audience that the Montreal Protocol for CFCs came about successfully precisely because science had agreed on a consensus path forward. When policy-makers were ready to commit to CFC reduction, the science was ready. Agreement on how to measure a unit of Carbon for carbon trading markets arguably took a decade; now a metric ton of carbon is a routine measurement (notwithstanding market failures). Now, capital markets see biodiversity investment as an opportunity. Scientists have the capacity to meet and seize this opportunity without losing the science. Economists must help both parties take advantage of the window that is potentially open now, which can linger in inefficient purgatory longer, or be opened wider for all to benefit. Hence the intended audience is the natural resource economist or agricultural economist pool, and potentially state Ag/Environmental agencies. Participants will gain an understanding of some of the common goals between Finance and Science, how the disconnect in language may be holding capital back, and where there may be room to advance the dialogue toward more productive discourse that can mobilise additional funding pathways toward natural capital.
Workshop Structure
The workshop will be a series of presentations, moderated by Valerie Seidel who will open with the context and problem statement: Researchers are focused on developing, refining and better understanding the science behind biodiversity, and how best to measure it – with a plethora of metrics that range from species-specific to regional to global. The Finance sector, meanwhile, begs for a unit they can count, and consistently; while lessons learned from both Montreal Protocol for CFCs and the Wild West of carbon credits can inform this potentially historic opportunity for private capital. Speaker presentations will be followed by a roundtable discussion/panel set of questions, then discussion/Q&A.
Speaker 1: Hanna Fiegenbaum, External Expert on Price Formation and Sustainable Market Design, Nature Repair Markets, European Commission. Discussion of the substitution of financial capital and natural capital and how it is influenced by institutional design, definition of metrics, tradable units, and trading rules; assess the sequence of decisions, constraints, adaptations, and trade-offs that can strengthen, weaken, redirect, or partially offset intended effects. The talk will describe observed effects of these factors on unit prices in the English Biodiversity Net Gains UK market, and more broadly, on the role of nature credit markets in the conservation space.
Speaker 2: Christiane Ehringhaus, Senior Sector Economist on Agriculture and Rural Development @KfW Development Bank. Discussion from the development bank perspective of the nature of individual ecosystem restoration and preservation funding projects, and transaction costs associated with underwriting and evaluating ad hoc, specific projects. The discussion will consider the opportunity for standardizing some biodiversity metrics toward the goal of common units for lenders.
Speaker 3: Liz Heagney, Natural Capital & Analytics, Skjander/Research Director, Farming for the Future; Discussion of the challenges in Australian finance markets for voluntary biodiversity credit markets, and the outlook from the Finance perspective of demand through 2030. The potential role of market design will be contrasted with the existing systems in place, and discussion of potential impacts on outcomes.
Speaker 4: TBC